Abstract: Cysteine is an attractive target for peptide and protein modification due to its unique reactivity and its relatively low abundance in natural proteins. Metal complexes undergoing oxidative addition have been shown to be highly effective arylation reagents; however, nucleophilic aromatic substitution as a post-translational modification in peptides and proteins has typically been limited to perfluorinated- or nitro-arenes. Moreover, selectivity can be an issue with these methods when lysine or other nucleophilic residues are present. We present a highly selective method that uses air- and water-stable organometallic reagents for aryl thioether formation in peptides and proteins. The organometallic complexes are activated to nucleophilic aromatic substitution and the modified peptides are afforded after exposure to visible light. These reagents were found to be highly selective for cysteine arylation, and no reactivity was observed with any other nucleophilic amino acid. We synthesized a series of organometallic reagents, which allowed peptide and protein modification in high yields. Notably, the low steric bulk of the complexes also gave highly selective ortho-, meta-, or para-double substitution – allowing the synthesis of peptide macrocycles and asymmetric dithioethers. This method for cysteine modification is a valuable new tool for selective and versatile functionalization of peptides and proteins.